The Last Victims In Kibbutz Kfar Aza

The Last Victims In Kibbutz Kfar Aza

Cindy and Igal Flash

On the morning of Simchat Torah, Cindy and Igal Flash retreated to their safe room. For hours, they exchanged messages with their three daughters, clinging to hope that IDF forces had reached the kibbutz. Around 5 p.m., more than ten hours after the assault began, terrorists stormed their home and murdered them

Cindy and Igal Flash (Photo: Private Album)

Cindy and Igal Flash (Photo: Private Album)

The Last Victims In Kibbutz Kfar Aza

Cindy and Igal Flash

Minute by Minute Circle
06:29
~09:10
~09:20
~12:45
14:03
~16:15
~17:00
17:06
~22:30

The sequence of events

Minute by Minute

Click on the points on the timeline for a real-time tour. Clicking on the icons will display the event documentation.

06:29

The Alarms Begin

~09:10

“The Army is Already Here, That Should Help.”

~09:20

Avidor Goes on Live Television: “We Hear Gunfire”

~12:45

Cindy Plays On Her Phone “To Stay Sane”

14:03

“There are Soldiers Around and It's Encouraging”

~16:15

Last Conversations

~17:00

Terrorists Murder The Couple

17:06

Keren Tries To Reach Her Parents

~22:30

Keren, Avidor, And Their Baby Daughter Are Evacuated

Exit Media
Exit Media

Cindy (67) was born in the U.S to a Christian family. In 1979, she came to Israel to volunteer at Kibbutz Nir Am, where she met Igal Flash (66). She later converted to Judaism, and the two married and started a life together. In 2001, they moved to Kibbutz Kfar Aza with their three daughters—Maayan, Tali, and Keren. Over the past year, Cindy completed her 21-year tenure as the administrative coordinator of the Department of Public Policy at Sapir College and retired. Igal was a distinguished agronomist, widely recognized for his expertise in field crops, particularly cotton. On Saturday morning, as rocket alarms echo through the kibbutz, Cindy and Igal take shelter in their safe room with their dog, Tootsie. Cindy sends a message to her daughter Keren, who also lives in the Kibbutz with her husband, Avidor Schwartzman, and their baby daughter

Exit Media
The Home Of Cindy And Igal
The Home Of Cindy And Igal Photograph: Private Album
Exit Media
Text Exchange Between Cindy And Her Daughter Keren
Cindy
There's terrible noise - what about you?
06:34 07/10/2023
Keren
We're all in our room. What is this shelling?
06:35 07/10/2023
Cindy
There are missiles from Gaza, but most of the noise is our firing.
06:36 07/10/2023
Cindy
According to Kan 11, missiles are fired on Rishon LeZion, Central Israel, and the southern region.
06:38 07/10/2023
Keren
Wow
06:39 07/10/2023
Cindy
There is also a red alert in Beer Sheva
06:52 07/10/2023
Cindy
Also around Tel Aviv, Rehovot.
06:53 07/10/2023
Exit Media

Tali, the middle daughter, lives in the United States. When she hears about the unfolding events in Israel, she tries to reach her parents. Igal messages her: “There’s a terrorist infiltration across the southern and the Gaza border regions.” A few minutes later, Cindy writes: “The army is already here, so that should help”

Exit Media
Family WhatsApp Group
Tali
Is everything okay with you?
09:08 07/10/2023
Keren
09:09 07/10/2023
Keren
Is everything okay with you? Everybody shelter in their safe rooms
09:09 07/10/2023
Cindy
God bless you, my baby ❤️ 😰
❤️❤️❤️
09:09 07/10/2023
Tali
God bless you, my baby ❤️ 😰
Sweetie
09:10 07/10/2023
Tali
What's going on there exactly??
09:10 07/10/2023
Igal
There's an intrusion into the community, everyone's in the safe rooms
09:11 07/10/2023
Tali
In Kfar Aza? Also in Kibbutz Nir Am, they all shelter in their safe rooms
09:11 07/10/2023
Keren
There is infiltration of terrorists throughout the southern region and the surrounding area, reaching Ofakim and Sderot. They took over the police station in Sderot
09:11 07/10/2023
Tali
What madness
09:14 07/10/2023
Tali
I'm glad everyone's okay and hope it'll be over quickly
09:14 07/10/2023
Cindy
The military is already here, so that will help
09:15 07/10/2023
Tali
Amen
09:16 07/10/2023
Tali
So scary
09:16 07/10/2023
Exit Media

Avidor Schwartzman, Keren’s husband, goes live on Kan 11. He reports that he and his family are sheltering in their safe room as the sounds of gunfire echo nearby

Exit Media
    • Disable
    “Other Than What We Hear On The News, We Don’t Know Much,” Avidor Speaks From Inside the Safe Room Photo: From The Special News Broadcast On Kan 11
    Exit Media
    Family WhatsApp Group
    Maayan
    I just heard Avidor on live TV
    09:24 07/10/2023
    Tali
    I just heard Avidor on TV
    Did he speak?
    09:24 07/10/2023
    Maayan
    Spoke???
    Yes
    09:24 07/10/2023
    Keren
    Yes, they called him just now
    09:24 07/10/2023
    Cindy
    Where can I listen?
    09:24 07/10/2023
    Tali
    Well done
    09:24 07/10/2023
    Maayan
    It was broadcast on Kan 11
    09:25 07/10/2023
    Cindy
    🤗🤗
    09:25 07/10/2023
    Exit Media

    Cindy tries to keep herself occupied in the safe room by playing The New York Times' Spelling Bee word puzzle. At 12:45 p.m., she messages Keren on WhatsApp, asking if she has found the correct word in the game. Keren replies, “Do you really think I’m doing that right now? Who could?” Cindy responds, “I’m forcing myself—just trying to stay sane”

    Exit Media
    Correspondence Between Keren And Cindy
    Keren
    Are you guys all right?
    12:43 07/10/2023
    Cindy
    Yes - sitting in the safe room and waiting. What about you guys?
    12:44 07/10/2023
    Cindy
    Have you found the pangram?
    12:45 07/10/2023
    Keren
    Do you really think that's what I'm doing right now??? Who would be even capable?
    12:45 07/10/2023
    Cindy
    I force myself to keep my sanity.
    12:46 07/10/2023
    Cindy
    And also answers whoever texts me on WhatsApp.
    12:47 07/10/2023
    Keren
    ❤️
    12:52 07/10/2023
    Exit Media

    Keren reaches out to see how her mother is coping, and Cindy replies, “There are soldiers nearby—it’s encouraging.” Realizing the scale of the tragedy unfolding in the kibbutz, Keren writes, “The kibbutz will be in mourning for a very long time”

    Exit Media
    Correspondence Between Keren And Cindy
    Keren
    How are you?
    13:58 07/10/2023
    Cindy
    Still in the same state - waiting in suspense. There are soldiers around, and that's encouraging.
    13:59 07/10/2023
    Cindy
    What about you guys?
    14:02 07/10/2023
    Keren
    I really hope it'll end soon
    14:02 07/10/2023
    Keren
    The kibbutz is going to be in mourning for a very long time. I understood from Avidor that they haven't heard from Gilah and Izhar for quite a while, nor from Rotem Holin.
    14:03 07/10/2023
    Cindy
    Oh no.
    14:04 07/10/2023
    Keren
    Seriously, total chaos.
    14:06 07/10/2023
    Exit Media

    The power cuts out in both family homes for several minutes before returning. Keren, Cindy, and Igal continue to exchange messages. Igal sends a photo of Cindy lying protectively over their dog, Tootsie, in the safe room

    Exit Media
    Correspondence Between Keren And Cindy
    Cindy
    That's it - The power went out.
    16:15 07/10/2023
    Keren
    Ours went out and came back
    16:15 07/10/2023
    Cindy
    Here too.
    16:16 07/10/2023
    Keren
    What's your situation?
    16:43 07/10/2023
    Cindy
    Still the same. You guys?
    16:43 07/10/2023
    Keren
    ❤️
    The same. Leila sleeps at least
    16:44 07/10/2023
    Exit Media
    Text Exchange Between Keren And Igal
    Keren
    Your situation?
    16:43 07/10/2023
    Igal
    ❤️🙏
    16:50 07/10/2023
    Igal
    And you?
    16:50 07/10/2023
    Keren
    Still as the same
    16:51 07/10/2023
    beam
    Sleeping Lola
    16:51 07/10/2023
    Igal
    16:51 07/10/2023
    Keren
    ❤️❤️❤️❤️
    16:51 07/10/2023
    Igal
    Mom and Tuss are resting
    16:51 07/10/2023
    Igal
    Toots
    16:51 07/10/2023
    Keren
    Cuties
    16:55 07/10/2023
    Exit Media

    Terrorists break into Cindy and Igal’s home, storm the safe room, and shoot them dead. Cindy and Igal are the last civilians murdered in Kibbutz Kfar Aza on October 7. Although the exact circumstances of their deaths remain unknown, Cindy and Igal's family recounts seeing bloodstains on the wall, the floor, and their granddaughter’s crib inside the safe room. Tootsie, their dog, has been missing since the attack

    Exit Media

    Keren messages her parents, pleading, “Are you okay? Please answer me.” But no response follows

    Exit Media
    Keren Writes to Cindy
    Keren
    Is everything okay?
    17:06 07/10/2023
    Keren
    Please answer me
    17:06 07/10/2023
    Keren
    Mom???
    17:06 07/10/2023
    Exit Media
    Keren’s Messages To her Father, Igal
    Keren
    Is everything okay?
    17:02 07/10/2023
    Keren
    Dad???
    17:08 07/10/2023
    Exit Media

    Keren, Avidor, and their baby daughter are rescued from the kibbutz. A few hours later, they are evacuated to Moshav Hodayah

    The Day After

    10/8/23

    In Search Of Their Parents

    10/10/23

    The Family Is Notified: Igal And Cindy Have Been Murdered

    10/24/23

    Cindy and Yigal are Laid to Rest
    Exit Media

    Cindy and Igal’s children go to the police station in Herzliya to report that their parents are missing. Keren and her sister give DNA samples to aid the search efforts

    Exit Media
    Avidor Is Interviewed By Yoav Krakovsky On Kan Bet
    00:00
    00:00
    From: Bet Hanivharim, Kan Bet
    Exit Media

    A resident of the kibbutz informs Keren and Avidor that Cindy and Igal have been murdered. He had learned the news from a member of the security forces who fought in Kfar Aza. The next day, the family is officially notified by the authorities

    Exit Media

    The funeral of Cindy and Igal Flash is held at the cemetery in Kibbutz Shefayim, where the majority of evacuated residents from their kibbutz found refuge

    Exit Image
    Exit Media